Thursday, November 29, 2007

All India Institute of Mad Sciences

AIIMS or All India Institute of Medical sciences is the premier medical institute in India. Premier hospitals in India refer special cases to AIIMS for expertise. AIIMS boasts of having conducted many rare surgeries and operations.

Ask any medical aspirant in India where he/she wants to study and this is the name you will most likely hear. It is statistically nearly impossible to predict if you will get in through the undergraduate entrance examination, no matter how hard you study. Why, because for tens of thousands of applicants AIIMS selects less than 50 ( this was the number few years ago) . Does it mean they produce medical geniuses?

Take a look here . What is at stake here ? Ego or lives of 10,000 people? Why are they putting so many poor and helpless people at risk? If I had the power, I would fire all of them. They do not deserve to be called doctors. Unfortunately, this is the scene all over India. Hospitals and medical facilities all over India look upto AIIMS as a role model and a leader. And thus, they strike at whim. All this in a country which has healthcare delivery and doctors to patients ratio comparable(maybe worse) to sub-Saharan Africa.

This is not the first time AIIMS docs have stopped work. They do it for anything and everything. Recently , they stopped work on the reservation issue. As an ex-student at IIT Delhi situated nearby, I have heard horror stories of dirty student politics at AIIMS. If you happen to go to AIIMS wards, you can easily overhear stuff like " mar gaya naa, dekh ke dawai deni thee" ( See , the patient died. You should have checked properly before giving medicine) from medical interns. Try going there without a referral from a politician or a burauecrat. So much for geniuses.

Bloody spoilt brats!

Why should I be so upset, you may ask. Well , every tax payer should be. The research for which AIIMS is so famous is subsidized by my money. And yours. For what?

Tuesday, November 20, 2007

What can you do about it?

This is a post I had written more than a year ago, when I was working with a Bangalore based organization called Janaagraha.

What can you do about it?

Life sometimes changes its direction in unexpected ways, through an event which seems to be of little importance at the time. It happens to almost everyone and at most times the change is not so much in what we do but rather in how we think about doing things. My life changed the day I decided to skip a movie one pretty Saturday evening and landed up at Janaagraha's office . More about Janaagraha later.I have been associated with this organization for over four months now , in different programs ranging from public disclosure of BMP's finances to writing articles for their monthly publication. Across the board , a common trend is the lack of enough young people in community related activities. Almost all the people under the age of 35 are college or school students and very few of those are actually working at the local community level. But I live in Bangalore , so I must have missed counting a key segment of the population under 35. Ahaa , the young professional.Everyone , including John Kerry and a certain George W Bush, knows about the young professional in Bangalore. Highly skilled , well educated , motivated , with a well paying steady (sometimes not so steady) job, unmarried or just married , spotted often at Garuda or Forum or MG Road/Brigade road especially on weekends. Perfect! Only , sometimes I wish Kerry knew a little bit about this professional's city as well.Bangalore sucks! The awful roads , the flooded drains , the incomplete flyovers , the one ways , the smoke , the rising temperature , the electricity and water supply , the this and the that . This list is endless. Often this topic becomes a reason to engage in feel good afternoon banter about the role of a former Prime Minister. But more often than not , the young professional says , "I am unattached, I do not belong here. I abide by law and pay my taxes. I am calm and never get excited(except the one time when I watched Rang De Basanti)". Cynicism , then.Where does this cynicism come from ? How does it become so all pervasive? Is it part of our genetics or something that I imbibed along the way? To know the answer , I , the young professional need to step back in time , when I was at school. For all the history and civics and other social sciences I crammed up as a kid , was there a single moment I felt that I had a responsibility beyond my house or my school ? A responsibility not to spit my chewing gum on the street , or to keep my neighborhood park clean or to ask my mom not to empty her dustbin in the drain. No , never. If childhood is when I could have learnt to become responsible outside my house and school and my teachers and parents could not teach me such a basic thing , then maybe it is a collective failure. A lost opportunity which may not present itself again. See , it is so easy to be cynical , to blame "the system" . There is a popular phrase for such a thought process : "conventional wisdom" e.g. "the system" is corrupt , "the government" is inefficient, our "cultural values" are different and so on. John Kenneth Galbraith , the renowned American economist , defined conventional wisdom as associating truth with convenience , with what is aligned with our self interest and personal well being or promises best to avoid awkward effort or unwelcome dislocation of life. No wonder , we accept it so comfortably without understanding much about what the "government" or the "system" actually is.I do not claim to know or understand any of the problems that afflict my city , let alone the solutions. Heck , I don't even claim to know who or what a typical young professional is. But , at a personal level, I have asked this question to myself over and over again in the past few weeks. Should I leave the future of this city in the hands of "the system" and wash my hands off it? With my education , my skills, my ability to reason , my youth and my energy whether all I can do is twiddle my thumbs while the active citizenry comprising of mostly old and retired and some not so fortunate people slug it out in public meetings to solve my day to day problems , go through the budget of the ward works to make sure the drainage is working and ,in general, engage with the government to make Bangalore a better city to live in. I find it very offensive , and downright insulting , when a newly returned Indian (or NRI for the pun inclined) rattles off the list of ills that plague Bangalore and how there is no hope. It definitely helps to know that America took more than 200 years to get where it is today, and NRI's did not have any role to play in that process until the recent past.In the end , then, the debate rests on a very fine line between whether I just care about this issue and wash it down with regular pepsi at INOX or I am willing to take the extra step and let it agitate the hell out of me. What I eventually do and whether I want to shoot down a defence minister or talk to my ward sabha representative about a flooded drain is a matter of finer and minor detail which , if you believe me , can definitely be sorted out.I am sure each one of us has brilliant ideas and I invite you to generously comment on what I have written and what you think can or should be done about the issue as a whole .Remember , though , if it helps at all , that a doctor treats the disease not just the symptoms. Remember , as well , that this blog is just an effort to let a collective thought process evolve , so what YOU think is most important.

Tuesday, November 13, 2007

Number portability is here!

Mobile Number portability will be launched early next year starting in four metros. It will allow subscribers to switch service providers while keeping the same number. Full number portability, including that for fixed lines, will be introduced gradually thereafter.

Number Portability(NP) should have a huge impact on competition in telecom space. I said "should" and not "will" because its success will depend upon how easy/smooth the process of changing a service provider is. If the process is a long and winding one, I don't expect many to line up for the hassles ( like residence verification etc).

Historically, the introduction of NP has led to as many as 50% of subscribers changing their service providers in other countries. This implies a big premium now needs to be places on customer loyalty and controlling the churn rate. This also implies there could be differentiation of customer segments with different tariffs applicable for different sets of customers ( losing a customer who uses 600 minutes in a month is 6 times more expensive than one who uses only 100 minutes).

Monday, November 12, 2007

The new "Open" Messiah

The open source revolution that began with Linus Trovalds and his hugely popular Linux OS has a new leader. And it is none other than Google. There were a couple of announcements in recent weeks about the far reaching impact this search giant could make in our lives.

Android is a Linux based software platform for mobile devices being developed from the ground up by Google. The list of partners Google managed to rope in for this initiative, titled " Open Handset Alliance" , is astounding considering that Google has little exposure to mobile devices. From telecom carriers like Sprint and T-Mobile to semiconductor shops like Intel,Qualcomm and TI and from phone makers like Samsung,Motorola and LG to software companies including itself(!) , the alliance has all the players lined up for the game. The biggest absentee is Finnish giant Nokia. I won't be surprised if Nokia starts a similar alliance with European partners.

OpenSocial is more than an API. It is Google's response to Facebook. Facebook has transformed itself from a college social network to something of a maverick platform for sotware applications targeting fun - games,movie quizzes etc. More importantly, it is adding 200,000 users every day! OpenSocial tries to go one up on FB by allowing developers to develop application for one API and use it on multiple social networks including Engage.com, Friendster, hi5, Hyves, imeem, LinkedIn, MySpace, Ning, Oracle, orkut, Plaxo, Salesforce.com, Six Apart, Tianji, Viadeo, and XING. I guess that list covers pretty much every SN other than FB.

Sunday, October 28, 2007

Building brands - Lessons from TFA

I did not know about TFA (Teach for America) until I started researching business schools for my MBA. While browsing the jobs database of the one of the so called top schools , I saw their job postings. How does an organization motivate MBA' from top business schools, arguably the top aspirators in the topmost capitalist society, to devote 2 years of their lives working for peanuts?

Answer : Branding

TFA is highly selective, rejects a high percentage of applicants. Teachers from TFA are regularly hired by top investment banks like Goldman and top consulting firms. Candidates flaunt TFA experience in their resumes for admission to top business schools.

What TFA offers in two years is a challenge of a lifetime, teaching kids in under-priviliged inner city neighborhoods in America. Anyone who has read "To Sir with love" knows how difficult this job can be for experienced campaigners, let alone fresh graduates with no teaching experience.
TFA gives rigorous training to its hires before they start teaching. Teachers are paid a stipend/salary, so it is not voluntary.

Wendy Kopp proposed the idea of TFA in her thesis at Princeton in 1989. Obviously it had no takers then and even as late as 2000 , TFA faced funding problems. But TFA's success shows that if an idea has enough takers in the people who matter, funding can't be a deterrent. And in this case, the people who mattered were the graduates from top American universities. Looking at TFA as an alternative to careers in number crunching ( spreadsheet modeling/presentation making) , the response has been amazing.

TFA is a powerful concept in social entrepreneurship. Can it replicated in India?

Friday, October 26, 2007

National Do Not Call register

NDNC register is a database of numbers maintained by the government. The owners of these numbers do not want Unsolicited Commercial Communication(UCC). It is a strong step in safeguarding consumer interests in the Indian telecom sector. There are illegal and unauthorised consumer databases used by almost every telemarketer and they are readily bought and sold.

A telemarketer now faces a fine of upto 500 rupees for calling a number registered on the NDNC. The advent of NDNC is also generating new business models built around permission marketing.

This site shows how the process will work.

If you reside in India, please register on the NDNC and save yourself from spam and unwanted calls.

Wednesday, October 24, 2007

Ginger or Garlic?

We all know copy-cats exist everywhere, including the world of startups. But this copy is destined to take the top award. Not only does it copy the business model , but also takes a dig on the original's name.

Original - mginger

Copy - mgarlic

The copy is currently down, trying to make a more exciting paste for your curry.

Does it get funnier in the world of startups?